# Tantrums: Mostly a Skill Gap, Not Deliberate Defiance

> Why toddler tantrums are mostly a skill gap, not deliberate defiance: staying calm, not giving in, time-in or planned ignoring, and routines.

Stage: toddler - Topic: Behavior - Page: https://www.askcradle.com/guides/toddler/tantrums-and-emotion-regulation

Grounded in: developmental neuroscience on the developing prefrontal cortex, Siegel & Bryson's "upstairs brain" framing in The Whole-Brain Child, and AAP guidance on tantrums and planned ignoring.

## TLDR

- Tantrums are mostly a skill gap, not calculated defiance. Stay calm, don't give in, and talk once everyone is calm.
- Stay calm, name the feeling ("You're really mad we have to leave"), then problem-solve later.
- Steady routines cut down triggers like tiredness and transitions.

## The principle

Young children's brains (especially the prefrontal cortex, involved in impulse control
and emotional regulation) are still early in development. In Siegel and Bryson's framing, a
toddler or young child having a tantrum is often experiencing a genuine skill gap - they don't
yet have the regulation ability to handle the frustration - rather than deliberately
"misbehaving" in a calculated way.

## Why this reframing matters

Seeing a tantrum as a skill the child hasn't developed yet points toward coaching (naming the
feeling, staying calm, modeling regulation) rather than a response that escalates things.
Some tantrums are also partly learned (they get a result), which is why many programs suggest
calmly not giving in and giving attention once the child is calm. Approaches differ on whether
to stay close (time-in) or give space (planned ignoring); both are reasonable.

## What tends to help

- Staying calm rather than escalating (a dysregulated adult can't co-regulate a
  dysregulated child).
- Naming the feeling ("you're really mad that we have to leave") before problem-solving.
- Consistent, predictable routines, which reduce the frequency of triggers like
  transitions and fatigue.
- Not trying to reason extensively mid-tantrum - the child's reasoning capacity is
  temporarily offline; connection comes first, discussion after.
