Tantrums: Mostly a Skill Gap, Not Deliberate Defiance
Why toddler tantrums are mostly a skill gap, not deliberate defiance: staying calm, not giving in, time-in or planned ignoring, and routines.
Ask Cradle about thisTLDRThe short version, if you only have a minute
- Tantrums are mostly a skill gap, not calculated defiance. Stay calm, don't give in, and talk once everyone is calm.
- Stay calm, name the feeling ("You're really mad we have to leave"), then problem-solve later.
- Steady routines cut down triggers like tiredness and transitions.
The principle
Young children's brains (especially the prefrontal cortex, involved in impulse control and emotional regulation) are still early in development. In Siegel and Bryson's framing, a toddler or young child having a tantrum is often experiencing a genuine skill gap - they don't yet have the regulation ability to handle the frustration - rather than deliberately "misbehaving" in a calculated way.
Why this reframing matters
Seeing a tantrum as a skill the child hasn't developed yet points toward coaching (naming the feeling, staying calm, modeling regulation) rather than a response that escalates things. Some tantrums are also partly learned (they get a result), which is why many programs suggest calmly not giving in and giving attention once the child is calm. Approaches differ on whether to stay close (time-in) or give space (planned ignoring); both are reasonable.
What tends to help
- Staying calm rather than escalating (a dysregulated adult can't co-regulate a dysregulated child).
- Naming the feeling ("you're really mad that we have to leave") before problem-solving.
- Consistent, predictable routines, which reduce the frequency of triggers like transitions and fatigue.
- Not trying to reason extensively mid-tantrum - the child's reasoning capacity is temporarily offline; connection comes first, discussion after.
New to AskCradle? It's free, calm guidance for pregnancy, babies, toddlers and beyond, with no sign-in. See what AskCradle is.
Grounded in: developmental neuroscience on the developing prefrontal cortex, Siegel & Bryson's "upstairs brain" framing in The Whole-Brain Child, and AAP guidance on tantrums and planned ignoring.
General information, not medical advice. If something feels wrong, trust that and call your pediatrician or provider. See Sources.
Spotted something wrong, or want to say thanks? Give feedback on this guide - Report a problem with this guide